A fireplace mantel is one of the few places in a living room where you can display a collection of objects without taking up valuable floor space. Often, the difficulty is making those pieces work together, particularly if you favor vintage finds, unusual ceramics, or souvenirs collected over the years.
The secret is to arrange your mantel decor ideas around overall balance, not how closely the individual pieces match. Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward's former home offers a particularly beautiful example of how to get it right.
The fireplace ideas in their Westport, Connecticut home exhibit a collection of unusual objects arranged across their timber mantel. A pair of terracotta unicorn heads sit at either end, alongside brass candlesticks (much like these from Wayfair) and small framed etchings positioned in the center.
Somehow, despite its eclectic nature, the arrangement feels considered, with each object having its own place.
This gold candlestick offers a more modern take on the style seen in Paul’s home. Pair it with white tapered candles to recreate the same balance of warm metallics and timeless detail.
Hearth & Hand 4"x6" Brass Scallop Frame
A look at Paul and Joanne’s fireplace really emphasizes the importance of curated pieces, and how they can make a mantel feel special. This brass frame brings a similar sense of vintage charm, and would sit beautifully atop a traditional fireplace.
12 Pack White Candlesticks
Tapered candles are such an easy way to make a room feel mantel-finished. These bring a classic touch to an arrangement, much like Paul and Joanne’s, but work just as well on a dining table when you're hosting friends for dinner.
Who says bookends have to stay on a bookshelf? Paul and Joanne’s fireplace shows how sculptural objects can work just as well on a mantel, where this similar unicorn silhouette adds an unexpected touch of character.
A vintage-style gallery frame is an easy way to bring a little more character to a mantel. Its aged finish would feel beautifully at home alongside the other personal touches on Paul and Joanne’s mantel.
Beyond the mantel, this living room reminds us how textures matter. To get their look, start with this cushion cover. The delicate pattern adds color and Paul-approved, time-honored charm easily.
'We see this play out all the time when preparing homes for sale,' says T.J. Rubin, the president at Fulton Grace.
'In a living room, the fireplace is usually the first thing a buyer's eye lands on, and in listing photos it's often the anchor of the main shot. A balanced mantel photographs cleanly and makes the whole room feel ordered. But a mantel that's perfectly matched, with identical lamps and identical vases on each side, starts to look like a furniture showroom. Buyers can't picture a life there.'
Design expertise in your inbox – from inspiring decorating ideas and beautiful celebrity homes to practical gardening advice and shopping round-ups.
'Paul's approach fixes that,' T.J. says. 'Build a balanced arrangement with objects that have a similar height and visual weight, then let the individual pieces be different. The etchings don't need to match in subject, only in scale and framing. The candles hold the outer edges so the eye stays contained. If you're trying this at home, start from the middle. Put your most interesting piece in the center, then work outwards with objects that are similar in size. You can introduce something a little unexpected at the edges to give the arrangement more character.'
For a similar look, start by choosing one object to sit in the middle of the mantel. This could be a framed piece of artwork, a sculpture, or a particularly interesting ceramic. Then work outwards, using pairs of accessories with similar heights or proportions to keep the display balanced. Candlesticks are particularly useful, as they add height without taking up too much space.
Plus, you don't need to buy matching accessories to make your arrangement feel curated. Decorating with vintage finds and heirlooms can work well together when their size and placement are consistent.
Paul and Joanne's mantel is a wonderful example of how to display more unusual decorative objects without making the fireplace feel overcrowded. The individual pieces give it a personality that's so distinctive to them. It's no surprise, then, that it looks just as beautiful as it did in 2004, when it was first shared with the world.
Love celebrity news and interior design inspiration? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.